Matthew Brady's Movie Review of Project Hail Mary

Rating of
3/4

Project Hail Mary

"Amaze. Amaze. Amaze."
Matthew Brady - wrote on 11/08/26

I enjoyed Project Hail Mary, but I didn't love it. It reminded me too much of other movies, which made it feel somewhat disconnected. The film is a bit long, and the first half takes a while to get going. Still, the positives outweigh my concerns.

Everything, from a technical standpoint, is excellent, especially the visual effects, which looked flawless and seamless. The score was solid, and the cinematography was stunning. It's an interstellar journey where the science fiction elements serve as a backdrop, with emotion and heart taking center stage.

Ryan Gosling continues to impress with his presence, delivering another outstanding performance. He shows a wide range of emotions: sadness, fear, confusion, goofiness, excitement, frustration, and more. Much of the movie takes place in space, where his only interaction is with a rock-like alien he calls Rocky. The character of Rocky isn't a CGI model but a puppet that Gosling can physically interact with—a real acting challenge; engaging with just a puppet and making it both entertaining and emotionally compelling for the audience. Of course, there are flashback scenes of him on Earth with other humans.

Sandra Hüller as Eva Stratt, a German NASA director who has no sense of humor and keeps to herself until one karaoke scene, where she lets her guard down and sings Harry Styles' 'Sign of the Times.' She nailed the scene, and something about it stuck with you afterward. However, let's say that something later in the movie, upon a second viewing, will make you see that scene differently.

But the true heart of the movie is the bond between Rocky and Grace. It was one of the most adorable friendships in modern cinema, and I cared deeply about it. They say, and I don't remember who said it, but if you want audiences to care about a monster, an alien, or any non-human character, you give them a cute face with puppy dog eyes. Well, with Rocky, who has no eyes or face, you still manage to care about this pile of rocks, which is no easy task. It makes me so sad to think that something bad might happen to Rocky. That’s the film's emotional hook, and reflecting on certain scenes between them makes me emotional. Here are two characters from different species in the vast open space who find belonging in each other because they both feel lonely on their home planets. It's also hard not to think of Cast Away, where Tom Hanks names a white volleyball Wilson, and we all cried for a volleyball more than we do for living, breathing people.

I'm not surprised this is doing well at the box office because it is a crowd-pleaser and has been well-received by critics and mainstream audiences alike. I'm glad people are connecting with it, and what makes it even better is that it's a well-made movie on its own. An actually good movie making money is a wonderful sight.

It's a sweet, adventurous film with a sense of hopefulness during our dark times. It is the perfect escape.

Are you sure you want to delete this comment?
  
Are you sure you want to delete this review?
  
Are you sure you want to delete this comment?