Jase's Movie Review of J. Edgar

Rating of
2/4

J. Edgar

Big disappointment
Jase - wrote on 01/19/12

Dustin Lance Black and Clint Eastwood took what should have been a fascinating story and mangled it into a completely uninteresting movie. In short, it left out so much that should've been on screen and focused on the more boring details. And, while I'm not someone who needs a movie to be linear to enjoy it, J. Edgar is sort of ridiculous. It jumps around far too much and throws too many things at you. There's a voiceover to provide some clarity, but it does little to rectify the problem. Telling the story in a simpler way would've been a better decision, I think.

The lighting is also an issue. I understand the desire to create a dark atmosphere for such a paranoid, depressing character, but it was taken a bit far. You can barely see what's going on in some scenes because the lighting's so dim. I think Eastwood was taking a risk by trying to make the movie more dramatic, perhaps more artistic. Taking such risks should be encouraged; it's just that, in my opinion, it failed miserably here.

Having said all that, Leonardo DiCaprio couldn't have done a better job. It was a great performance that no one else could have given. It's unfortunate that the rest of the film didn't live up to it.

Are you sure you want to delete this comment?
  
Are you sure you want to delete this review?
  
Are you sure you want to delete this comment?