Yojimbo's Movie Review of Panic Room

Rating of

Panic Room

"Panic Room" by Yojimbo
Yojimbo - wrote on 02/02/12

When thieves break into a New York home they thought would be empty, the occupying woman and her teenage daughter find refuge in the panic room, unaware that it is the target of the intruders' plan. David Fincher had a lot to live up to when he made this film, which makes it all the more perplexing that he chose such a generic and unimaginative script for his follow up to Fight Club. In fact if anything, the directorial flourishes that worked so well in the context of the off-beat idiosyncracies of that film just look out of place and pointless here and despite the slight Hitchcockian vibe it all seems too overly familiar. Jodie Foster gets to showcase her cleavage, spending the whole running time of the film in her underwear, Kristen Stewart has little to do except look sickly and the villains each have their specific stereotpyes, the pick of the film being the ever reliable Whitaker as the criminal with a conscience. There are a couple of major plot contrivances that just didn't work for me and there is little in the way of surprises along the way. It is a solidly made, decent quality Hollywood thriller, but I've come to expect more from Mr. Fincher.

Are you sure you want to delete this comment?
Are you sure you want to delete this review?
Are you sure you want to delete this comment?