Movie Information
Overall Rank: 19441
Average Rating: 2.1/4
# of Ratings: 38
Theatrical Release Date: 03/18/2005
Language: English
Genre: Comedy, Drama
MPAA Rating: PG-13
Director: Woody Allen
Actors: Radha Mitchell, Chloë Sevigny, Will Ferrell, Amanda Peet, Josh Brolin, Steve Carell
Watch Trailer
Add to List
Request Correction
Write Plot
Write Review Quick Reviews
Full Reviews
Movie Lists
Movie Talk
Quick Movie Reviews
Rating of
2/4
Logan D. McCoy - wrote on 06/26/2019
The premise is more interesting on paper than on screen, as the comedy side of "Melinda and Melinda" isn't all that memorable or funny, and the drama half is just wooden.
Rating of
2.5/4
Lauren - wrote on 07/07/2012
Wasn't the greatest of Woody Allen's films. Definitely good plot and very clever as always but I was kind of bored...? I don't know. It was funny and very good I just didn't find myself loving it.
Rating of
2/4
mitchellyoung - wrote on 07/24/2011
There is a lot of promise in the premise, which purports to present two versions of the same story - a comic and tragic version. However, the script is too obsessed with being clever and misses the life and innate wittiness of past Allen films. The cast are all performing well under their potential here.
Full Movie Reviews
Rating of
1.5/4
****face and Douchebag
Snake Sugarbaker - wrote on 12/11/2009
Woody Allen's latest, Melinda and Melinda, has a promising premise: In a familiar Allen scene where pretentious, cardigan-clad, arty folk philosophize over wine in public, two playwrights discuss a situation they've overheard. That situation belongs to Melinda, an unstable, travel-worn woman who interrupts an important dinner party by unexpectedly arriving at her friends' Upper East Side apartment. One playwright (Larry Pine) envisions Melinda's background as a tragedy, while the other (Wallace Shawn) invents a comedy. Director Allen, however, looks at both, and the film delineates the playwrights' respective takes, essentially making two films.
The only constant in the two stories is Melinda, the unannounced guest, endearingly played by Radha Mitchell. The tragic tale has Melinda, …
Related Movie Lists
Ranking Woody Allen Movies by Logan D. McCoy
Woody Allen (director filmography) by Cinemaniac
Recent Movie Talk Posts
No posts have been made on this movie yet. Be the first to start talking about Melinda and Melinda!
