Create Game Lists on MeltedJoystick.com
FilmCrave home
   Movies  Members
Search +
Searching... Close  
Are you sure you want to delete this comment?
  
 
  Login Using Facebook
Twitter
 
     
 

The Golden Compass (2007) Movie Reviews

Your Rating:
 
 
Buy The Golden Compass (2007) DVD from AmazonBuy The Golden Compass (2007) DVD from Amazon  Add to List: Add to movie listWrite Review +Request correction +Submit a plot +

Full Movie Reviews

1 - 8 of 8 

  View TheSteelCat's Profile
TheSteelCat
Rising Star
 

07/09/2008 (0 of 0 found this helpful)

The Rusty Compass

The CGI and effects save this movie, without a doubt. The plot is shaky and not very convincing to the point where you sometimes barely know what the hell is going on, combined with a child doing a very, very awful cockney accent; a small part, but, yes it was that bad that it needed to be addressed.

The film calls in the services of Daniel Craig, after his soaring roles as "James Bond" and he was advertised to be on the film, a film in which he appeared for very little and seemed to be a meaningless character, which brings me on to my next point.

If you are a die-hard Golden Compass book reader, then you would most probably like the film, but if not then you may find that this film won't make much sense to you.


As stated earlier, the CGI and effects are brilliant and are put t...

Rating of
2/4 

read more +
 
Write comment +View all reviews + Was this review helpful? Yes   No
 
 
  View Josh C's Profile
Josh C
Producer
 

07/07/2008 (0 of 0 found this helpful)

Why is everyone hating on this movie? It's great!

I don't understand all the negative reviews. I waited over a year to see this since the reviews were bad so it just kept falling off of my list of movies to watch. When I finally did watch it I was startled at how good the story was.

The movie reminded me of Harry Potter, with all the magic and mystery, but I thought it was presented better. There was more action, better special effects and far less whining. Overall, it was a complete joy to watch and my only problem with this movie was the ending because I wanted more and didn't want to wait for the next one.

The acting was also good. Nicole Kidman's cold blooded character was really effective and Dakota Blue Richards showed she has a lot of potential.

The story was darker and had a more grown up message, which was probably w...

Rating of
4/4 

read more +
 
Write comment +View all reviews + Was this review helpful? Yes   No
 
 
  View Franz Patrick's Profile
Franz Patrick
Movie God
 

01/17/2008 (0 of 0 found this helpful)

As a Fan of the Books, This is a Good Introduction

It's good enough as an adaptation of the book. Sure, there were quite a handful of choppy moments which made me wonder why they showed certain scenes in the first place but one can't deny the imagination and effort that came with this film. I suppose a lot of people were expecting a new "Harry Potter" or "Chronicles of Narnia" franchise and were disappointed to find that this isn't one. I found Nicole Kidman and Dakota Blue Richards to be effective as two polar opposites. As a fan of the trilogy, I do hope that in the next movie, the filmmakers wouldn't be afraid to offend the church. Sure, money needs to be made and the more commercial the film, the more money they would get. Still, is greatness worth trading for money? In this case, I'm more forgiving. But if there happens to be a seque...

Rating of
3/4 

read more +
 
Write comment +View all reviews + Was this review helpful? Yes   No
 
 
  View phantom's Profile
phantom
Producer
 

12/15/2007 (1 of 1 found this helpful)

two hours wasted

I should say at the outset, I have not read the books therefore I cannot judge its accuracy. I will say there's no way the books could be this dull and still have been read by anyone.
Golden Compass is not the worst film ever made, but it is certainly horrible.
It was two hours of absolute boredom. When it finally became interesting (which was maybe ten min.) it was over. A guy in the audience when I saw it actually shouted out, "Dude, what the..." My sentiments exactly.
Dakota Blue Ricahrds who plays Lyra, the protagonist, is a whiny spoiled brat and her acting just comes off as incredably flat.
The rest of the cast is wasted on such a picture. Christopher Lee and Derek Jacobi apear in one scene. Daniel Craig is there at the begining and then disapears. And Ian McKellan as the polar...

Rating of
0.5/4 

read more +
 
Write comment +View all reviews + Was this review helpful? Yes   No
 
 
  View OK Rick's Profile
OK Rick
Producer
 

12/13/2007 (1 of 1 found this helpful)

The Golden Dumpass

What did I think of this movie? Screw that! I have a better idea. Let me just reach into my leather, Prada bag here. Hmm. A wallet, my insect in a tin can collection...Ahh, there it is. My alethiometer. I'll just move the three hands which help to guide me to the truth. We'll put one on the baby, one on the lute and one on the bird. Now, I just have to hold the question in my head. "Was this movie any good?" Hold on. The "truth" hand is moving. It's pausing on snake, pausing on snake again and it's stopped on the hourglass. That means evil, evil, death. This movie was awful. Hold out your hand movie. Hold it out. Bad movie! Very, very, bad movie.

The entirety of the this movie was dirt poor. I could type for hours and hours as to why, mostly because it takes me ab...

Rating of
1/4 

read more +
 
Write comment +View all reviews + Was this review helpful? Yes   No
 
 
  View Chris Kavan's Profile
Chris Kavan
Movie God
 

12/10/2007 (0 of 0 found this helpful)

Fool's Golden Compass

The Golden Compass film is directly related to Nicole Kidman's character: it looks great but it ultimately cold and soulless. The striking visuals make a great treat for your eyes, but the story feels rushed and none of the characters have any spark to give life to the film.

It's a bad sign when your most emotional character is a CGI bear with the deep, caring voice of Ian McKellen. The film always seems to be better anytime the polar bear warriors show up on screen. The bear battle scene is the highlight of the film, even more so than the ending battle between all feuding parties.

Speaking of feuding parties, those going into this film lightly are in for a surprise. Keeping everything straight is a chore: you have witches, and Gyptians and Magisteriums and bears and kids and skypi...

Rating of
2.5/4 

read more +
 
Write comment +View all reviews + Was this review helpful? Yes   No
 
 
  View newmans_own's Profile
newmans_own
Director
 

12/08/2007 (0 of 0 found this helpful)

Watered down and rushed through intro to Pullman

THE GOLDEN COMPASS races from one important point to another, leaving no time in between for a breather. It acts as a 101 course to Pullman’s world; most of the scenes involve someone sitting Lyra down and explaining things. The viewer is talked at almost relentlessly; something that becomes rather irritating in a film that proclaimed to be an epic adventure. The source’s more controversial points have been severely eased. Anyone coming into the film without prior knowledge would find the film’s stance against the Magisterium to be a mild attack on the current government, and nothing more. The entire situation is very vague; sure, they’re villains, but no one really explains why, other than a few “well, they’ve kinda done this” statements.

As Lyra, Richards brings a smart, assured port...

Rating of
2/4 

read more +
 
Write comment +View all reviews + Was this review helpful? Yes   No
 
 
  View BryanFury's Profile
BryanFury
Producer
 

12/08/2007 (0 of 0 found this helpful)

They should have called this The Boring Compass

Sadly The Golden Compass would be just another name in the long list of most forgettable movies this year. What disappointed me most was the lack of story and substance the film brought to the table. Yes the effects were there, but real reason the people are watching this is because of the golden compass itself. But not even its power could have save this film from bad reviews and criticism. I find myself loosing interest on the main reason the movie exists. The compass was sort of boring so to speak. Its power was to tell the truth and it has like four hands to do that, again boring. The lack of interesting storyline would be the key factor for this film’s demise. Such a shame, they could have done a lot better with the material they have. They could have shown the audiences something ne...

Rating of
2/4 

read more +
 
Write comment +View all reviews + Was this review helpful? Yes   No
 
 
1    
 
 
Log In
Help on how to log into FilmCrave
Login with Facebook
Login with FilmCrave
 
 
What Members Are Doing
Movie Talk
New Movie Reviews
New Movie Lists
My viewing tracker list. by James
Movies of 2017 by Stoney McStonerson
Best Movies of the 2010s by Mr Cinema
2016 Rated and Ranked by Chris Kavan
Movies Watched by Sunbutt
Top Films of 2007 by Neobowler
2016 by Karmand
Movies to Watch by royaluglydudes

 

 

 

Contact FilmCrave Public Relations    

Advertise and Business

Developer API

Contact Us

Jobs

About us

SiteMap

 

Support FilmCrave

FAQ and Help

News and Press

Terms of Use

Privacy